Undivided Ownership contact
Successory indivision is an essential concept that comes into play when a loved one passes away. This legal framework automatically arises during the transfer of an estate and often leads to numerous questions. What rights do heirs have? What rules govern the use and management of shared assets? How can one bring an end to this often-complicated situation? This comprehensive guide will help you understand this legal principle and its implications.
What Is Successory Indivision?
Successory indivision refers to the scenario where multiple heirs collectively inherit and co-own the assets of the deceased. Upon the passing of an individual, their estate is automatically transferred to their heirs, who collectively become co-owners of the assets. This shared ownership continues until the estate is formally divided.
For example: Imagine a widow, aged 80, passes away, leaving four children as her heirs. Her estate includes a studio apartment, a house, a bus, and a savings account. Upon her passing, all four children inherit equal shares of these assets. Each child, therefore, owns one-quarter of the house, one-quarter of the bus, one-quarter of the studio, and one-quarter of the savings account. This example highlights how successory indivision works.
This stage of shared ownership is meant to be temporary. It concludes when the estate is divided, whether through a mutual agreement among heirs or via judicial proceedings.
Key Conditions for Successory Indivision
As an heir, you have specific rights regarding shared assets, but these rights come with conditions designed to protect all parties involved. Below are the primary conditions you should be aware of:
1. Unanimous Consent: The use of shared assets typically requires the agreement of all co-heirs.
2. Respect for Others’ Rights: Heirs must ensure that their actions do not infringe upon the rights of other co-owners or disrupt the intended use of the assets.
3. Compensation for Exclusive Use: If an heir uses a shared asset exclusively, they may be required to compensate the other heirs financially.
Ideally, heirs will reach an amicable agreement on how to divide the assets, which simplifies the process. However, disagreements often arise, making the management of the shared estate more complex.
Management and Sale of Shared Assets
Managing shared assets during successory indivision involves specific rules, particularly when it comes to decision-making and the sale of property. Here are the key points:
1. Decision-Making by a Two-Thirds Majority: Routine decisions, such as administrative tasks or covering maintenance costs, require the approval of co-heirs representing at least two-thirds of the ownership rights.
2. Delegation of Management Duties: The co-heirs may appoint one individual to oversee the management of the estate. This manager is expected to regularly update the other heirs about their actions.
3. Unanimity for Real Estate Sales: The sale of shared real estate assets typically requires the unanimous consent of all co-heirs.
Additionally, heirs have the right to incur expenses for preserving shared assets. These costs are reimbursable either by the estate itself or by the other co-owners.
Ending Successory Indivision
Successory indivision concludes when the estate is divided among the heirs. This division can occur in one of two ways:
1. Amicably: The heirs mutually agree on how to divide the assets fairly.
2. Through Legal Proceedings: If disagreements persist, the court steps in to determine how the assets will be distributed.
Another potential resolution is for one heir to buy out the shares of the other co-owners. This approach allows one individual to retain ownership of specific assets while financially compensating the others.
French law also places a five-year limit on successory indivision unless the heirs sign a formal agreement to extend it. Known as an indivision agreement, this document—governed by Article 1873 of the French Civil Code—outlines the management rules for the estate and ensures that no co-heir can unilaterally demand a division. If the estate includes real estate, this agreement must be notarized. It typically lasts for five years and can be renewed.
How to Resolve Successory Indivision
Navigating successory indivision can be challenging and restrictive. Important decisions, such as selling an asset, usually require unanimous approval from all heirs. Fortunately, there are several ways to exit this situation:
1. Selling or Donating Shares: An heir can transfer their ownership rights to other co-heirs, usually with the assistance of a notary.
2. Selling Shares to an External Party: If an heir wishes to sell their shares to an outsider, the other heirs have the right of first refusal, giving them the option to purchase the shares before they are sold externally.
3. Asset Division: The estate can be divided either through mutual agreement or, in cases of conflict, through a court ruling.
Judicial Proceedings for Division
If heirs cannot agree on how to divide the estate, they can initiate legal proceedings. Typically, this process takes one to two years in the first instance. However, courts may postpone the division if it risks diminishing the value of the assets.
In certain cases, a surviving spouse may request to maintain indivision for a maximum of five years, provided specific conditions are met.
Conclusion
Successory indivision is a critical but often contentious phase in the inheritance process. While it serves as a transitional stage, it can lead to disputes and complications. Understanding your rights, responsibilities, and available solutions can make managing this situation less daunting. Whether through open communication among heirs or judicial intervention, resolving indivision allows for clarity and proper allocation of assets, providing a fair resolution for all